.

.
...get help with your essays and dissertations with MyEssaySearch

Pages

Mindingthecampus.com:Race-Class-Gender in History Dissertations

I found this blog on Race-Class-Gender in History Dissertations which I think is very useful for those who wanted to get some rough ideas on what dissertation topic to work or perhaps those who wanted to know the most sought after topic in the world of dissertation writing. Check out the portion of the blog or you may follow the link below to read the entire article.


Inside Higher Ed features a somewhat odd analysis about a study by the AHA comparing words in the titles of dissertations that appeared between 1920 and 1960 with those that appeared in the last 20 years. According to IHE's Scott Jaschik, "For the recent titles, some of the analysis may challenge conventional wisdom about the state of the disciplines. There has been much discussion in recent years from some historians who say that issues of race, class and gender have come to dominate history, at the expense of traditional studies of politics and war. But the new AHA study found that 'war' appeared in 11 percent of dissertation titles and 'politics' appeared in 7.6 percent of titles. By contrast 'women' and 'gender' appeared in 7.8 percent of the titles, and 'race,' 'ethnic' and 'ethnicity' appeared in only 4.5 percent of the titles."

As Jaschik points out, the statistics are clearly meaningful in one respect: the decline of dissertations with France or England in the title suggests a geographic shift away from Western Europe.

Regarding subdisciplines, however, these statistics say little if anything. First, while it's quite true that the race/class/gender paradigm extends everywhere geographically, its focus has been on history of the United States. (It's hard to imagine, for instance, issues of "race" appearing with much frequency in the historiography of China.) While all large and many small universities make U.S. history hires that are specific to the subfield/discipline, few schools do so for any topics outside of the United States. Analyzing the percentage of dissertations about Burmese history that contain the word "race" in the title tells us little about the historiography of the United States.